REVIEW: The Commitments at Birmingham Hippodrome

We reviewed the current production of 'The Commitments earlier in its run. This review is an updated version of a previously published one.


The Commitments could be described as a celebration of soul music, wrapped in the premise of a working class fairytale. However, what it definitely is, is two hours of feel-good, laugh out loud brilliance.

Based on the 1987 novel and the 1991 film adaptation, The Commitments premiered in 2013 at the Palace Theatre in the West End and was quickly hailed as a smash hit.

It's the story of Jimmy, a young working class music fan who shapes an unlikely bunch of amateur musicians and friends into an amazing live act - in fact, by his own admission, the finest soul band Dublin has ever produced. The band get to know each other and their instruments, and proceed through early rehearsals for their first gig, however just as they improve and begin to get a name for themselves...they fall apart.

The backing singers are all getting off with a middle aged horn legend, the lead singer has entered Eurovision as a solo artist (and not told anyone!) and the saxophone player has dangerous leaning towards a jazz career.

First thing's first - this isn't a jukebox musical. Roddy Doyle, the man behind every incarnation of the piece points out that, as all the songs are performed by the band rather than being sung by characters to express an emotion, the show transcends that sub-genre.

However, technicalities out of the way, what The Commitments does so beautifully is create a piece which doesn't take itself too seriously, isn't afraid to poke fun at its characters and wraps it up in the greatest hits album we all want from Santa this Christmas!

I saw the production earlier in its run and thought that we'd fallen lucky and caught the cast on a (very) good day. There was no conceivable way they could replicate the first time round this evening, could they? Well...no. They couldn't replicate it. They could better it.

The soundtrack to The Commitments is one of the stand-out stars of the show. With over 20 soul classics performed live, including 'River Deep, Mountain High', 'In The Midnight Hour' and 'Mustang Sally', I defy someone with even just a basic grasp of music to not know at least half of what's on offer. This show is hit after hit and the songs are performed so brilliantly by such a phenomenally talented cast, it's almost impossible to stay in your seat and not join in.

I think its fair to say that the storyline isn't exactly Rodgers and Hammerstein. The plot is fairly straightforward but is the perfect conduit for the performances. 

Ben Morris took on the role of Deco tonight and quite literally blew us away. With his incredibly rich and soulful vocal, Morris played the role like he'd been doing it for an eternity. He seemed so comfortable in Deco's shoes - a role which he alternates on tour - that he was a pleasure to watch.

Morris's voice is quite simply exceptional. Channeling more than just a hint of soul giants like Mick Hucknall, his tone was stunning and drew spontaneous applause from the crowd and an involuntary standing ovation after the last note hit.

Alongside Morris, James Killeen was our Jimmy - a character who formed an unlikely double-act with Deco. Not quite Morecambe and Wise in style, but one where the chemistry between the two performers was evident with Kileen playing a man who was clearly managing his frustration with a group of very individual band members, so competently.

Mention should also go to Ciara Mackey (Imelda), Eve Kitchengman (Natalie) and Sarah Gardiner (Bernie) for the most stunning vocals throughout. The trio have undoubtedly gotten better the more they sing the songs - and all three of them hit each harmony perfectly. Their performances of songs like 'Knock On Wood' were some of the stand-out moments of the evening.

Whether you want to see some good Irish humour or belt out some classics, The Commitments definitely won't disappoint.

The show runs at Birmingham Hippodrome until Saturday 29th April 2023. For more information, or to get your tickets, visit birminghamhippodrome.com.

Recently Played

DOWNLOAD OUR APPS

  • Available on the App Store
  • Available on Google Play

Useful Links

Weather

Travel News

How To Listen

Latest Podcasts

92.2 / 102.5 FM
Online
App
'Play Black Country Radio'